Thomas (boggyb) wrote,

  • Mood:

Amy's Choice

I've finally gotten round to typing up my musings on the last couple of episodes. You won't have seen them in your friends pages as I backdated the posts, so follow the links to read my musings on Flesh and Stone and The Vampires of Venice. Then come back here for today's episode.

"That's something that doesn't make sense... let's go and poke it with a stick."

The start of this episode confused me for a bit, as historically there's few if any developments in the time between episodes (if that makes sense). Then we get them walking in a too-empty street, and someone creepy peering out from a window... and then they wake up in the Tardis. Ah, so I've not missed a bunch of episodes.

Then the dream master turns up, and now the fun starts. My guess for most of the episode was that the Tardis world was the real one, and the village was the dream, as the Tardis world is closest chronologically after the previous episode. Thinking about it, another way to solve this puzzle would be to try and remember what's happened - if the village is the real world then you can remember what you did to escape the cold star, while if the Tardis is real then you should have little or no memory of between the Tardis and the village.

Of course, the problem is then that *both* are dreams, which I did not see coming but makes some sort of sense in retrospect. The whole thing of falling asleep in one world and waking up in another is the kind of thing that would be utterly crazy in the real world but to your dream self would make perfect sense, to the point where you're not even aware that it's only in a dream where that could happen. The dream master did also seem to give in too easily, almost as if this was a game rather than anything more real. Which it is - it's the Doctor, daydreaming that he is the dream master. Except... how do you know that you've finally left the dream?

On the dream master being a representation of the Doctor: they seem to be making a point over the last few episodes that this Doctor is not nice. This is very much a thing of the tenth and eleventh Doctors - the ninth was a lot nicer, though he was also a lot more of a coward. #10 and #11 (especially #11, after seeing what he almost did in The Beast Below) would likely have actually used the delta wave thingy in The Parting of Ways, while #9 cheerfully admits he could never do so as he's too much of a coward.

Oh, and no crack in this episode either. Have they abandoned the arc image?
Tags: doctor who

  • Computer specs

    The first part of the long-overdue computer rebuild posts! Back in May, I finally brought my desktop kicking and screaming into the current…

  • Skyward Sword HD: for SCIENCE!

    One thing I've noticed from playing through Skyward Sword HD is how... underwhelming the skyward strike appears, at least to begin with. It takes a…

  • Random quote

    pleaseremove, setting a work quiz: "No, I'm going to get my wrong answers right"

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.